The Future of Hindus in Pakistan is Bleak: India Today

24 May

The resignation of MLA Ram Singh Sodha, 67, from Pakistan’s Sindh provincial Assembly last year, and migration with his family to Kutch had created waves both in India and Pakistan. His move was seen as a signal of the increasing persecution of Hindus by radical Islamists in Pakistan. Sodha, a lawyer, spoke to India Today’s Senior Editor Uday Mahurkar in Nakhatrana in Kutch but he was cautious, as many of his relatives are still in Pakistan. Excerpts:

Q. How do you see the situation in Pakistan today?

A. Pakistan still has a large number of moderate Muslims willing to live cordially with Hindus but they have been overwhelmed by the fear of the bombs and guns of militant Wahhabis who are ready to die while killing their religious rivals. The situation is turning grave though things are better in lower Sindh where the local Sindhi Muslims follow Sufism and take care the Hindus.

Q. What was the immediate provocation for you to flee Pakistan?

A. Militant Wahhabism has almost entered upper Sindh, travelling down from Punjab. Unless a miracle happens, it’s a matter of time before it percolates to lower Sindh too. I migrated as a long-term self-preservation measure. Plus, we Sodhas of lower Sindh have always married in the Jadeja Rajput clan in Kutch. So we have historical ties on this side. Otherwise there was no immediate provocation for me to leave Pakistan.

Q. Do you fear retaliation? Is that why you are hiding the real truth?

A. Not at all. I will speak only the truth. You can’t ignore the fact that militant Muslims are targeting moderate Muslims with more violence.

Q. What is the difference between Jinnah’s Pakistan and today’s Pakistan?

A. In Jinnah’s Pakistan, religious minorities were protected while in today’s Pakistan, even moderate Muslims who want to peacefully co-exist with people of other religions are insecure now. Jinnah’s word was betrayed immediately after his death but the real change came in the ’70s when General Zia-ul-Haq gave a long rope to radical Islamists taking advantage of the Afghan war. He also created separate electorates for Hindus thus virtually making them second-class citizens.

Q. What is that thing that amazes you the most in Pakistan?

A. The irony that the land which produced Frontier Gandhi, Khan Abdul Ghaffar Khan, should produce the most dreaded Islamic militants on the face of the earth.

Q. When was the first time that you felt insecure in Pakistan?

A. In 1986-87 when, in reaction to the Ram Janmabhoomi movement in India, some temples were vandalised in Sindh province.

Q. What is the solution?

A. Both India and Pakistan should wage a joint war against the militants and I am of the firm opinion that the common people of both the countries want aman (peace) from the violence of the militants.

Q. What will be the fate of Hindus of Pakistan?

A. Apart from the worsening religious situation, the fate of Hindus also depends on the Indian Government. The government should be more liberal in its treatment. A Hindu Pakistani migrant gets citizenship only after seven years of stay in India, during which time he cannot work or even start a business. This minimum period should be brought down to three. As for Hindus who choose to stay in Pakistan, their future appears bleak.


Posted by on May 24, 2011 in Hindus


Tags: , , , , , , , , , , , ,

2 responses to “The Future of Hindus in Pakistan is Bleak: India Today

  1. Adnan Sattar

    May 24, 2011 at 7:30

    Dear Sadaf: Eye-opening. Like your blog. During a recent visit to Tharparkar, I was surprised to find how common it is for local people (belonging to the Hindu community, of course) to migrate to India. Typically you get a family or pilgrimage visa, and once across the border in Rajhastan, you settle down permanently with relatives. People also end up getting Indian citizenship after a few years. Surprised also that the Indian government has never taken this issue up to chastise Islamabad for its treatment of minorities!! In one local NGO I visited, at least 30% staff members had a close relative-sibling or a first cousin-living on the other side of the border in Jodhpur or some place in Gujrat. I haven’t come across any research or a journalistic piece on the scale of the phenomenon. Have you? Hard not to believe it though after hearing so many firsthand accounts.

  2. Sadaf Arshad

    May 24, 2011 at 7:30

    Dear Adnan,
    I am glad that you took this time out to visit the blog. If you ask me I believe all the Hindus who happen to be in this country would like to leave for India. In previous years, a massive migration has been witnessed. The reasons behind this move are upsetting and embarrassing. They are clearly unhappy over here and lack a sense of belonging. This country has not put up much effort to bring them closer or tried to invoke the feeling of unity. So eventually it all led to great dissatisfaction among them. Why India has not raised this issue with Pakistan has an obvious reason. The bilateral relationship between India and Pakistan suffers blows time and again and mistrust is deep-rooted which has seen another dimension of terrorism now. So India would not bother to get in these petty issues, petty for them. Above all, national interests and diplomacy have a different world where these people do not exist.
    Best Regards,


Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s

%d bloggers like this: